Category Archives: Fishing Reports

Fishing Reports

Eagle River – 10/24/2025

Time: 11:30AM – 3:30PM

Location: Private water between Wolcott and Eagle

Eagle River 10/24/2025 Photo Album

My friend, Dave G., who lives in Eagle Ranch near Eagle, CO belongs to a fishing club with access to private water on the Eagle River. Dave G. invited me to join him on Friday, October 24, 2025; and I accepted the invitation pending favorable weather. When I checked the weather forecast for Friday, I noted that the high near Eagle, CO was in the mid fifties, so that clinched it, and I made the drive on Friday morning.

Held Aloft

I arrived at a wide pullout at 10:45AM, and Dave G. arrived within a few minutes. We car pooled a short distance to a dirt parking area across from the private section of the Eagle River. The dashboard temperature was 46 degrees, so I pulled on my fleece hoodie and rain jacket along with my billed hat with earflaps. I was prepared for the worst. I chose my Sage One five weight in anticipation of tangling with some muscular trout of above average size. The river was quite turbid, and the color resembled a creamy split pea soup. Dave G. said it rained within the last twenty-four hours, but not that heavily, so he was perplexed with the lack of clarity. We walked to the edge of the river to inspect more closely, and we concluded that it would fish decently with two feet of visibility along the edge.

The Waterway Ahead

I waded across the murky river at the wide tail of a shallow pool, and I progressed along the far bank (south bank?). To begin I chose an amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, olive perdigon, and salvation nymph. In short order Dave G. landed a couple fish on a zebra midge, and I was shut out, so I followed suit with a black zebra midge with a fine copper rib. Finally after an opening drought, I connected with a fish and hauled a nice, fat thirteen inch rainbow trout into my net. The zebra midge was in its lip, and I was amazed that a fish saw the tiny midge larva imitation in compromised river clarity.

Lots of Foam

I continued onward, and before I broke for lunch I landed two small brown trout. One was around eleven inches and the other was smaller. The first and smaller brown nabbed the zebra midge, but after another dry spell, I swapped the zebra for a psycho prince and then an apricot egg. The second larger brown grabbed the olive perdigon.

Decent Brown Trout

After lunch and another slow phase, I exchanged the egg fly for a return to the salvation. Between two and three o’clock the temperature peaked, and I removed my raincoat and folded up the earflaps on my hat. The pace of action improved, and I managed to land a chunky fourteen inch rainbow and a small rainbow barely greater than six inches. Both fish snatched the olive perdigon. In addition, I hooked and failed to land three decent trout during this time, and I sensed that they favored the olive perdigon. Was the increase in action attributable to the warming water temperature, improved water clarity, or my fly choice? I suspect all three, although the improved effectiveness of the olive perdigon along with less olive tinged water suggested clarity as a prime reason.

Love the Riffle Sections

By 3:30PM I reached the end of the private section of the river, so I reversed direction to another wide shallow crossing spot. Dave G. indicated that he was fished out, so we called it a day and returned to our vehicles. Friday was a slow day on private water, although had I landed all the fish I connected with, I may have reached double digits. I was appreciative of Dave G.’s willingness to invite me to share the private water. Was this my last outing of 2025? The answer depends on the weather with a turn to colder temperatures predicted for Tuesday. Stay tuned.

Fish Landed: 5

South Boulder Creek – 10/22/2025

Time: 11:00AM – 3:30PM

Location: Below Gross Reservoir

South Boulder Creek 10/22/2025 Photo Album

What a day! October 22 is kind of late in the season for this fair weather angler, but the high in Denver was projected to climb into the seventies, and when I checked the two locations close to my intended fishing destination, the weather indicated temperatures in the sixties. I decided to pay an autumn visit to South Boulder Creek.

Source of Early Trout

The flows were reduced at 17 CFS, but I knew from previous experience that I fished successfully at 10 CFS. Low clear flows would dictate stealthy approaches, longer casts and light flies. I was prepared.

So Pretty

I arrived at the Walker Ranch Loop Trailhead, and I quickly geared up with my Sage R8 four weight. For clothing I wore a short sleeve high tech undershirt and my fishing shirt, but I loaded my backpack with my raincoat and a long sleeve Under Armour shirt. If I perspired excessively, I planned to change undershirts, before I began to fish.

Another Early Rainbow Trout

There were three cars in the parking lot besides my Telluride, but none of them were obviously fishermen. In fact, I never saw another angler during my entire time on the creek, nor did I encounter any on my hike to and from the stream. I had the entire small tailwater to myself. Perhaps the low flows scared away other anglers.

Shelf Pool

As I descended the trail to the creek, I heard the sound of heavy equipment operating to the west. Almost instantly I went into panic mode, as I envisioned the 17 CFS as a muddy mess from excavation taking place at the dam expansion site. You can imagine my relief, when I caught my first glimpse of the creek, and it was crystal clear.

Stealth Required

When I finally arrived at my chosen starting point, I concluded that I was perspired but not to the degree that I required a shirt change. I began my quest for South Boulder Creek trout with a solo peacock size 14 hippie stomper, and the dependable fly yielded three fish including a nice eleven inch brown.

Fine Rainbow Trout

After the early success, the trout’s interest in the stomper seemed to change into observation, and refusals ruled the day. I paused at 11:45PM to enjoy my lunch, and then afterward I replaced the hippie stomper with a size 14 olive deer hair caddis. The caddis produced a few fish to boost the fish count to seven, but it was very difficult to track in the glare and shadows, and it also elicited some refusals.

Next to the Exposed Boulder Was a Target

My mind went into overdrive, and I considered the idea of a beetle. Hatches are rare late in the season, but the 2025 autumn has been unusually mild thus enabling the survival of terrestrials. I knotted a size 14 Jake’s gulp beetle to my line, and I added a sunk ant on an eighteen inch dropper. Large black ants are quite prevalent in the South Boulder Creek canyon.

Very Nice Brown for a Small Stream

The move paid handsome dividends, and I built the fish count to eighteen, before I once again stalled. Five of the eaters during this span of time gobbled the sunk ant, but the rest sipped in the beetle. In addition I experienced many temporary hook ups, where the trout nipped the beetle, and I set and connected, but the fish wriggled free in a short amount of time. Beetle takes are very subtle probably because the small foam fly rides low in the water, and the fish dart to the surface and execute a quick sip.

Another Brown Trout Run

When I got stuck at eighteen, I began to notice an increased number of airborne insects over the water. The naturals included small caddis, a couple mayflies and a stonefly. This observation prompted me to swap the sunk ant for a size 16 gray deer hair caddis. The beetle and caddis combination raised the fish count from eighteen to twenty-four; its final resting place before I quit and completed the exit hike.

Large Tail

Twenty-four trout landed on a fall day in October is very satisfactory, but of course, many of the fish were small and in the six to nine inch length slot. However, I also landed a fat thirteen inch rainbow and two fourteen inch brown trout that challenge for the largest browns that I ever landed in South Boulder Creek. The second brown smacked the caddis near the end of the day.

As predicted, the weather was gorgeous. I had the stream completely to myself and the beetle was a solid attractor. I took advantage of one of the remaining nice days of 2025, and I am pleased with the results.

Fish Landed: 24

Arkansas River – 10/15/2025

Time: 12:00PM – 3:30PM

Location: Pridemore State Wildlife Area

Arkansas River 10/15/2025 Photo Album

Wednesday was projected to be the nicest day of the week, so I cleared my calendar for another day of fly fishing. A high in the seventies in Denver translated to a high in the upper sixties near Salida, so I made the Arkansas River my destination. The flows were in the 300 CFS range, and this meant I could probably cross the river and fish the bank away from the highway in one of my favorite hangouts below Salida.

Salvation Nymph Eater

I departed Denver at 8:00AM, and heavy traffic on Interstate 70 prompted me to use the Express Toll lane for $5.50. The move saved me fifteen minutes, as my estimated arrival time moved up from 11:00AM to 10:45AM. Unfortunately that was the one piece of good news that preceded a series of unlucky events. When I merged on to CO 470 on the western side of Denver, I passed two gravel trucks, and I heard a loud thwack on the windshield. I immediately cursed my misfortune, and when I stopped for gas on the way home, I inspected the windshield and discovered three chips that joined the curved crack already in place. It is impossible to keep a windshield free of cracks and chips in the state of Colorado.

Deep Seam Produced

As I drove southwest on US 285, I found myself creeping along at 25 miles per hour behind a row of vehicles in a 50 MPH speed limit zone. I stared ahead, and there was a huge road construction vehicle with flashing amber lights, and the slow moving caravan crept along for a mile, before we stopped, where a flagman was displaying a stop sign. Fortunately the delay only lasted a few minutes, and the westbound traffic that included me was allowed to proceed. This little stoppage slipped my estimated arrival time by five minutes.

Decent

Bubble Line

I finally arrived at my chosen destination along the river below Salida, and I quickly jumped out of the car to inspect the river. Imagine my disappointment, when I observed murky flows in the river below me. I immediately returned to my car and dialed the ArkAnglers Fly Shop, and the helpful young man who answered informed me that rain and snow were causing the turbity. He said that a couple feet of visibility existed along the edges, and fishing was still a possibility. He also volunteered that most of the murkiness was generated by the South Fork of the Arkansas River, and he suggested that I could leap frog that tributary to find clearer conditions. I thanked him for his useful information, and I decided to move upriver above the South Arkansas River.

Olive Perdigon

Of course, there was construction in progress in Salida, so I was forced to detour, but this delay was minor, and I arrived at the Arkansas Headwaters Stone Bridge access area by 11:30AM. I geared up and rigged my Sage One five weight, and then I ate my lunch. The temperature was 65 degrees, but it felt colder because of the gusting wind, so I pulled on my light raincoat as a windbreaker.

Chunk

I was finally ready to fly fish, so I hiked along the top of the bank for .4 mile, until I reached the downstream boundary of the public water, and then I cut down a steep bank to the river. For my opening act, I chose a size 8 amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, an olive perdigon, and a salvation nymph.

Model Brown Trout

I began migrating upstream, and I was very particular about my casting targets. I skipped wide areas, as they presented relatively shallow riffles and pockets, and the probability of landing fish was low. Instead I focused on deep seams and pockets next to structure. The approach paid dividends, as I landed eight brown trout between 12:00PM and 3:30PM, when I quit for the day. I covered a significant amount of river real estate and ended my day on the north side of CO 291 at the Stone Bridge boat launch ramps.

Bubbles and Rock Bottom

The first four trout grabbed the nymphs, with one nabbing the olive perdigon, and the others were attracted to the salvation nymph. Once I hit four, the action stalled for thirty minutes, so I changed out the olive perdigon for a 20 incher, and the chubby/20 incher/salvation remained my lineup for the remainder of the afternoon. During this time I boosted the fish count from four to eight, and the final four were wild browns in the thirteen inch range. My success accrued from swinging and lifting the nymphs as has been the case on my recent fall outings. All the fish that I landed grabbed the salvation nymph, but it seemed like the 20 incher was a more effective partner to the salvation than the olive perdigon.

Pocket and Exposed Rock

Wednesday was a nice October day aside from the annoying wind. I overcame quite a few obstacles to fly fish for 3.5 hours on Wednesday, but I managed to land eight wild fish including five brown trout in the twelve to thirteen inch range. Quite a few attractive places failed to produce, and I worked hard for my catch, but I was satisfied with the results. I suspect that spawning activities are in progress, and this perhaps explained the relatively slow action. This may have been my last visit to the Arkansas for the year, and it was a solid day of fishing on the big river.

Fish Landed: 8

Eagle River – 10/13/2025

Time: 11:00AM – 3:30PM

Location: Between Avon and Wolcott

Eagle River 10/13/2025 Photo Album

Monday, October 13, 2025 was Indigenous Peoples Day, and I decided to make it a day of fly fishing. What, you say? Why Indigenous Peoples Day and not Columbus Day? Indigenous Peoples Day is the official name of the holiday in Colorado, and I am a Coloradan. In addition, I believe that the culture and beliefs of Native Americans more closely align with my personal ideology. Native Americans were and remain stewards of the land and environment. They lived sustainably, before we even knew the meaning of the word. The Native Americans realized that the land, air, water and wildlife were what enabled them to carve out a living in the New World.

Upstream Beauty

Typical Productive Spot

When I surveyed the prospects for Monday, weather was a significant concern. I set my sights on the Arkansas River, the South Platte River and the Eagle River. Weather forecasts for all three included high temperatures in the fifties and rainfall. The highs for the Arkansas River near Salida and the South Platte River in Eleven Mile Canyon were in the low fifties; whereas, the highs near Avon and Edwards were mid-fifties. The probabilities for rain were also higher in Salida and Lake George, so I decided to gamble on the Eagle River.

Getting Larger

An uneventful drive allowed me to arrive at my chosen spot by 10:00AM, but the temperature was 48 degrees, the wind was blasting from the east, and rain was coating my windshield with moisture. I questioned my judgement for choosing to fish under such adverse conditions. I sat in the car with the engine and heat running, while I listened to sports talk and completed my favorite New York Times games. After fifteen minutes I forced myself to utilize the Port-a-let next the parking lot, and then I decided to face the elements and begin my day of fishing. I could always quit and return home.

Look at Those Colors

Along the Rocks on the Bank

By the time I layered up with my Brooks long sleeve shirt, fishing shirt, North Face light down parka, fleece hoodie, and raincoat along with my billed hat with earflaps, the rain stopped. I rigged my Sage R8 four weight and ambled along the road a short distance to the river. I followed a bike path downstream and then cut to the river near my exit point on my last Eagle River fishing outing.

Loving the Submersion

I began my quest for trout with an amber ice dub body chubby Chernobyl, an olive perdigon, and a salvation nymph. This lineup has become my go to combination in recent fall fishing trips. Between eleven o’clock and 12:15PM I netted seven decent fish, and I was quite pleased with the action. Three of the seven were rainbows and four were browns. The salvation nymph was the favorite fly in the early session, with a few nabbing the olive perdigon. As was the case in recent visits to the Eagle River, I sought areas where the riverbed narrowed thus creating deeper runs, seams, pockets and riffles. Most of these locations also contained large exposed boulders which provided cover and protection for the cold water fish.

More Opportunity

After lunch I continued with the dry/dropper; and, in fact, this approach was utilized for the remainder of my time on the river. Within fifteen minutes after lunch, a trout grabbed one of the nymphs and instantly ran beneath a branch that was wedged in front of an exposed rock. I waded upstream a bit to get above the snag, but the current was very fast and deep. I managed to position myself above the boulder, and I could leverage the branch up a bit with my wading staff, but the fast current pushing against the branch was stronger than my feeble efforts to counter it. I was in a precarious position, and not wishing to lose my footing, I applied direct pressure and broke off the valuable perdigon and the salvation.

Fat One

This was my third lost salvation, so I replaced it with a PMD supernova. Later in the afternoon I also lost the supernova and replaced it with an ultra zug bug. By 12:30PM the sky cleared, and the weather improved immeasurably. and my good fortune continued. I boosted the fish count from seven at lunch to sixteen by the time I quit at 3:30PM. The quality of the fish throughout the day was outstanding. All but two fish were twelve inches or greater. Nine rainbows arrived in my net compared to seven brown trout. This ratio was different from my earlier experience on the Eagle, so I concluded that some portion of the brown trout population was in spawning mode.

Wild Mint

The fish of the day was a seventeen inch brown trout that gobbled the olive perdigon. I cast to the middle of a featureless wide section, and the brown tugged the chubby under, and I was attached to a large fish. The brown relied mostly on a diving and rolling routine in its efforts to escape, but I was able to counter its best moves and coaxed it into my net. What an unexpected thrill! Why wasn’t this beast procreating?

Big Head Todd

Look at the Length and Girth

Just before the brown trout confrontation, I connected with a fifteen inch pink striped rainbow. As is the custom with wild rainbows, it incorporated hot streaks in its escape effort, but once again my four weight possessed enough backbone to bring it to the net. Besides these highlights, most of the fish were in the thirteen to fourteen inch slot, and they were all wild and fresh in the cold autumn flows of the Eagle River.

Back to Chubby Rainbows

My most effective techniques were swings at the end of drifts on across and down casts and lifts at the end of a drift before the river spilled over or around a rock. Dead drifting was also a winning approach, and one nice rainbow smacked the chubby Chernobyl on a directly upstream cast and drift.

Lavender Stripe

On Monday, October 13 persistence paid off. I outlasted the rain and wind and cold, and I was rewarded with a very satisfying day of fly fishing. Sixteen trout in the middle of October is outstanding, and the quality of the fish was exceptional. I was warm throughout the day, and I was even too warm toward the end of my time on the river. The Eagle River has been a top producer in 2025, and I may try to visit the freestone river again in 2025.

Fish Landed: 16

Blue River – 10/08/2025

Time: 11:00AM – 3:30PM

Location: Between Silverthorne and Kremmling

Blue River 10/08/2025 Photo Album

For quite some time now my fishing friend, Nate, has been touting the Blue River, so we arranged for a trip on Wednesday, October 8, 2025. We agreed to meet at the Woolly Mammoth parking lot just off of Interstate 70 at 8:00AM, and I arrived a bit early. As I waited for Nate to arrive, my iPhone rang, and I answered and heard the voice of Nate. He was calling to tell me he had a blowout on Interstate 70 just beyond the last on-ramp before the exit to the parking lot that I occupied. He dropped me a pin, and I circled around the interstate ramps, until I was parked in a precarious position behind his VW. We were in a triangular space between the on-ramp and high speed traffic blasting by on Interstate 70.

Nate had already extracted his temporary spare and tool kit, and he made the change over expeditiously. My only contribution was to observe and advise, and he did learn from me to loosen the lug nuts before jacking up the tire, and to fully tighten once the car was lowered back to the ground.

Once Nate’s tire was replaced with the spare, we carefully got on the entrance ramp and returned to the Woolly Mammoth lot. I was the obvious choice to drive, since Nate’s temporary spare advised to not drive over 50 MPH.

Nate Ready to Roll

We arrived at our chosen destination to fish the Blue River by 10:30AM. The temperature was 51 degrees, so I pulled on my North Face light down coat and raincoat. I chose my Sage One five weight for casting in case I tangled with a larger fish, and also because the flows were elevated at around 700 CFS. We hiked down a bank and along the river for a mile, and we began fishing in a long and wide riffle section.

I began my efforts with an amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, an olive perdigon and a salvation nymph, and I was certain that I was going to enjoy a productive day in a new section of the Blue River that I never fished previously. Nate, likewise, launched his day with a dry/dropper set up.

In the half hour before I broke for lunch I made a host of futile casts, and my confidence seemed misplaced. Nate, meanwhile landed a small brown trout during this time period, and he delayed his lunch.

Love the Drop of Water Off the Lip

After lunch we progressed up the river, but the fishing was truly a challenge. I was having no luck in the long slides and troughs, so I began to skip the featureless areas and focused on shelf pools, moderate depth riffles and deep slots around structure. In addition to unresponsive trout, we were plagued with a nasty cross wind that pushed my backhand casts back toward my body and bushes and branches along the shoreline.

Site of First Brown Trout

Over the course of the afternoon I cycled through different flies including a 20 incher and RS2 for nymphs and a hippie stomper and size 16 olive-brown deer hair caddis for dries. For the last 20 minutes I tested a black ghost streamer and a white and tinsel streamer. How did these flies produce? I landed two trout; a nice chunky thirteen inch brown that munched the olive perdigon and a smaller brown trout that grabbed the classic RS2. That was it. I spotted some tiny mayflies, midges and caddis; and these sightings prompted the RS2 and caddis dry. I worked the double/dries along the bank thinking that some opportunistic bank huggers could be tempted, but that ploy was to no avail.

Nice Colors

The streamers failed to generate so much as a follow, but I was pleased I stepped out of my normal routine to try them. I did not test a deep nymphing setup with a strike indicator, and given the elevated flows, I regret that oversight.

It was a gorgeous fall day among spectacular scenery, and I scouted out new water with my good friend, Nate. Hopefully I will return at a future date with lower flows and more insect activity.

Fish Landed: 2

Big Thompson River – 10/07/2025

Time: 11:30AM – 3:30PM

Location: Below Lake Estes

Big Thompson River 10/07/2025 Photo Album

After a non-fishing weekend in the Flattops, I was anxious to resume my sampling of western waters in 2025. I made plans to fish with my friend, Nate, on Wednesday, so I was reluctant to make a long drive on Tuesday, and I decided to visit the Big Thompson River. The flows were a favorable 51 CFS, and the high temperature was expected to peak around the mid-fifties, which is in my tolerable range.

I arrived at a pullout in the canyon below Lake Estes a bit after 11:00AM, and I quickly geared up with my rod choice being my Sage R8 four weight. The dashboard registered 51 degrees, and the sky was quite overcast. I judged that the sun’s rays would not be warming things up to a great degree, so I wore my Under Armour long sleeve undershirt, fishing shirt, North Face light parka, and raincoat. For head gear I pulled on my billed hat with earflaps. I was concerned that I dressed too warm, but I was glad to have the layers throughout my day on the stream.

Not a Bad Start

My day can be divided into three segments. The first was the morning, when I deployed an amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, an olive perdigon, and a salvation nymph. I used these flies for thirty minutes before lunch and netted a couple small rainbow trout.

Nice Pocket

After lunch I switched to a peacock hippie stomper and trailed a size 14 caddis in a double dry arrangement. In the first session the chubby attracted a few refusals, so I concluded that the trout were looking to the surface for their food; and, thus, the double dry. The hippie stomper accounted for one fish as did the caddis, but the two surface flies followed the lead of the chubby Chernobyl and produced quite a few refusals. By 2:00 the fish count rested on seven, but I suffered a long dry spell, so I modified my approach for segment three on the day.

Another Respectable Brown Trout

I replaced the hippie stomper with a tan body mini chubby, since trout were attracted to the chubby Chernobyl in the early session, but refused to eat. I bet that a smaller chubby with a tan body might generate improved effectiveness. Next I downsized the trailing dry fly to a size 16 deer hair caddis with an olive body. The small caddis yielded a trout, but, otherwise I was no better off.

Slots Along the Far Bank

I noticed a few tiny blue wing olives in the air, so I reverted to a dry/dropper with the mini chubby leading an olive perdigon and size 22 sparkle wing RS2. This combination produced a few fish to elevate the fish count to ten. During this time the most effective technique was an across stream cast, and then I held my line high to keep the fly line off the water, while the flies drifted downstream, and I completed the maneuver with a lift. This action seemed to spur the interest of the fish.

Better Side

By 3PM the sparse hatch was over, and I once again endured a slump, so I exchanged the RS2 for a bright green caddis pupa. The caddis pupa and the mini chubby fooled a pair of fish, and I ended my day by 3:30PM with the count at twelve.

Nice Little Pool

After fishing the last pool, before I quit, I looked up and was a bit startled to encounter a young fly fisherman. He was playing a fish, and his rod was in a significant bend. He asked if I could net the fish for him, so I waded within range, but as I approached, the fish dove under a large exposed boulder. The young angler climbed on the rock and reached down and pulled the leader away from the rock and freed the fish. By now I was within range, and I could see that the fish was foul hooked, so I scooped it into my net. The young man thanked me and quickly announced that he forgot his net. He said that the fish hit the dry fly on the second cast, and it was his first trout landed in Colorado. I asked him where he lived, and he said Pennsylvania, and I told him I was also from Pa. He was from the western part of the state, and he was in Loveland, CO on a job and searched on line for a nearby stream. I was pretty happy for the young man and his early success.

Tuesday was a so-so day on the Big Thompson River. I managed to hit double digits, but the fish were small. Six of the landed fish were browns in the nine to eleven inch range, but the fish count also included a bunch of six and seven inch dinks. I was never able to find a consistently productive fly or combination. It seemed like the fish were not selective, but they also were not very hungry. I was pleased to record one more day with reasonable weather before the winter cold moves in.

Fish Landed: 12

Clear Creek – 09/27/2025

Time: 1:00PM – 3:30PM

Location: Clear Creek Canyon

Clear Creek 09/27/2025 Photo Album

What is it about Clear Creek that keeps pulling me back? The trout are small and fussy, and wading the rocks is like skating on marble. I suppose the redeeming quality that pulls me back is proximity. I can drive to the middle of the canyon in forty minutes, if traffic is normal. On an early fall Saturday in September the traffic was not normal. My Google maps app displayed three stretches of yellow and red highway. I was concerned that the bottleneck resulted from construction, but it was strictly attributable to volume. The canyon was alive with rock climbers, dog walkers, hikers, cyclists, leaf peepers and fishermen.

I arrived at a small parking lot at 12:45PM, and I immediately pulled on my waders and fit together my vintage Sage four weight. When I was ready, I hiked down to the creek and crossed to the bank across from the highway.

Nice Lighting

To begin I tied on an amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, a beadhead hares ear and a salvation nymph. In the first thirty minutes I landed one small brown trout. I was disappointed with this result, so I replaced the hares ear with an olive perdigon in the top nymph position. This combination yielded another small brown trout, but the chubby was drawing interest in the form of refusals. The frequency of refusals was not that exciting, but it was still better than the avoidance of nymphs.

Prime Spot

I removed the dry/dropper and proceeded with a double dry approach. Initially I offered a peacock ice dub body hippie stomper and a size 16 light gray caddis. The caddis duped a fish, but the stomper attracted undue attention in the form of empty looks and refusals.

Love the Pattern

For the remainder of the afternoon I worked my way upstream to the next Peak to Plains bridge, and I increased the fish count to six. I cycled through the hippie stomper, a size 16 light gray deer hair caddis, a size 14 Jake’s gulp beetle, a parachute hopper, an olive stimulator, a Chernobyl ant and a size 14 olive deer hair caddis. The beetle was the only fly to account for multiple fish at two, and the stimulator notched one.

A Fish Emerged from Just Beyond the Wood Structure

It was a very lackluster day on Clear Creek on Saturday. I landed six small brown trout between six and nine inches in 2.5 hours of fishing, and it was a disappointment in my book. Only one other angler was in my zone, so that was a positive, and the return drive was devoid of stoppages. Of course, I was coming off three outstanding days of fishing from September 22 through 24, so Clear Creek was burdened with a tough comparison. I may not be able to fly fish again next week, so it was good to get on a stream.

Fish Landed: 6

Eagle River – 09/24/2025

Time: 11:15AM – 3:30PM

Location: Between Avon and Wolcott

Eagle River 09/24/2025 Photo Album

Wednesday was my day to return to Denver, so I decided to pay a visit to the Eagle River. On September 17, 2025 I spent a day on the freestone river near Vail and Avon, and I did pretty well, although it took me a while to solve fishing in relatively low flows. On Wednesday I was very anxious to apply my learnings.

Heck of a Start

After storms passed through on Tuesday night, the temperature dropped, and the weather forecast called for highs in the upper sixties. More relevant was the hourly forecast, which suggested that the temperature would be in the upper forties between 10:00AM and 11:00AM. I took my time. I arrived at a favorite pullout by 10:30AM, and by the time I pulled on my gear and assembled my Sage R8 four weight and hiked to the river, it was 11:15AM. The temperature was indeed 48 degrees, so I wore my Under Armour long sleeve shirt, my fishing shirt, my hooded fleece, and my raincoat. I swapped my usual broad brimmed hat for a billed cap with earflaps, and I showed respect for the chill by pulling up my fleece hood, I was cozy, but I never removed a layer throughout the day. The dashboard temperature, as I began my return drive to Denver was 65 degrees. Fall is imminent in the Rocky Mountains.

Top of Long Pool

I began my day at the forty yard long super pool that I love. After reading my blog post from 09/17/2025, I decided to copy the same lineup. I tied on a size 8 amber ice dub chubby Chernobyl, an olive perdigon and a salvation nymph. Well, not exactly. I had a PMD supernova in my fleece with a leader attached, so I substituted it for the salvation, as they are quite similar in size and color scheme.

Another Eagle River Beast

Deep Trough

I began at the middle section of the long pool, and I lobbed long casts toward the center, where the river created a nice bubble line and seam. I planned to continue fanning casts across the river in this manner, until I reached the entering currents at the head of the pool, I followed this plan between 11:15AM and 11:45, and I was rewarded with two amazing trout. The first grabbed the perdigon near the midsection, and after a tough battle I netted a muscular fifteen inch brown trout. What a beginning!

Defined Stripe

Another Deep Pocket

I moved halfway up toward the faster run, and I slung a long cast across the river to a seam within eight feet of the far bank. As the flies began to swing away from the bank at the end of the drift, something grabbed the PMD supernova, and I immediately sensed a brute. The fish did not react instantly, but as soon as it realized that an annoying fake nymph was in its mouth, it went into escape mode. The brown thrashed and dove and streaked and rolled on the line, but my fly did its job, and I netted an eighteen inch brute. I was astonished. The fly was wedged in the lip of the big brown, and I was struggling to remove it with my fingers. I finally conceded that my fingers were not up to the task, and I pulled out my hemostat for more leverage. I succeeded in removing the fly, albeit in a bent state, but in the struggle, my prize brown finned away and robbed me of a photo. Despite the unfortunate failure to photograph the giant brown, my mind retains a vivid image.

Yikes. Fat Browns Continue Coming

On my September 17 outing I discovered that the most productive water existed, where the riverbed narrowed and thus created deeper runs, slots and pockets for the fish. I planned to apply this insight to my day on Wednesday, and this meant that I skipped around wide shallow sections and slow moving segments. After lunch I waded to the midsection of the large pool and made some up and across casts, where the river fanned out a bit from the faster and deeper top half. On one of the swings the chubby darted, and I set the hook, and I was once again attached to a freight train of a brown. Unfortunately it was foul hooked, but it was another example of the healthy fat brown trout in the Eagle River.

Foliage Changing

For the remainder of the afternoon I progressed east along the river. I  used the bike path as a highway and skipped the long wide riffle section above the long pool, and eventually clambered down a short steep bank to the river. I used the shoreline to continue to a stretch, where the river narrowed, and I found the type of structure that I was seeking. Huge exposed boulders were scattered about, and the faster current carved deep runs, pockets and slots among the rock garden.

Big Flapper

Trough Between the Two Exposed Rocks

I spent the remainder of my day casting to this type of water, and the results were outstanding. I landed twenty-two trout, and only six of the total catch were beneath twelve inches. All the others were twelve inches or greater, and the size was skewed toward the fourteen to fifteen inch range. Only four of the day’s catch were rainbows, but one made up for scarcity of species by measuring around sixteen inches. It was a gorgeous fish.

Lavender-Pink

A host of brown trout rounded out the numbers, and these were fish to be admired. All were well fed and apparently were putting on weight for the fall spawning season. The most effective technique was to cast across and allow the flies to swing at the end of the downstream drift. Quite a few respectable brown trout could not resist the escaping salvation nymph, which I substituted for the bent PMD supernova after lunch. The perdigon accounted for a few as well, but the real workhorse fly in the afternoon was the salvation.

Just Wow.

As I write this report I remain filled with euphoria. It was extremely gratifying to recognize the type of water that produced trout on September 17 and then adhere to a strategy that conformed to my September 17 observation. This was easily a top ten day for 2025 and perhaps top five. I am still marveling at the size and quality of the trout that visited my net. Hopefully I will have an opportunity to revisit the Eagle River again in 2025, before the weather gets too adverse.

Fish Landed: 22

Frying Pan River – 09/23/2025

Time: 10:30AM – 4:30PM

Location: Below Reudi Reservoir

Frying Pan River 09/23/2025 Photo Album

After a spectacular day on the Frying Pan River on August 19, 2025, I was anxious for a return engagement. Tuesday, September 23 would be that date. It rained steadily on Monday evening into Tuesday morning, so I felt fortunate to be visiting a tailwater. The DWR chart reflected steady flows of 170 CFS, Tuesday’s high in Basalt was forecast to reach only 60 degrees with cloud cover and light precipitation in the picture.

When I arrived at my chosen pullout at 10:00AM, the dashboard thermometer registered 48 degrees. I was not acclimated to these colder temperatures, so I wore my Under Armour long sleeve undershirt, my fishing shirt, my fleece hoodie, and my light down North Face. In addition, I dug out my billed hat with earflaps. I wore this entire ensemble all day, and I was comfortable.

Perfection

To begin I configured my line with the flies that served me well on August 19. The surface fly was a tan size 8 pool toy hopper, and below the hopper I tied a 20 incher and salvation nymph. I was aware that I was thirty days removed from the day in August, but the flies were not particularly tied to a specific hatch.

Typical Frying Pan River

From 10:30AM until 11:45AM I progressed up the river, and I managed to guide three small brown trout into my net. I cycled through the salvation nymph, a hares ear nymph, a supernova PMD, and a RS2 in an effort to generate action. The hares ear delivered two and the 20 incher one. I spotted some very tiny mayflies, and this prompted my test of the RS2, but it was totally ignored.

Nice Grip

I ate lunch in the car, and then I migrated up the river a couple miles. I encountered quite a few anglers at one of my favorite locales, but I parked among three other cars and cut through the trees to a spot just below a split in the river around a small island. I persisted with the dry/dropper, and I built the fish count to ten, before I reached the spot, where the river merged and ran next to the road. At this point I decided to reverse my direction to fish the smaller left braid.

Magnified Tail

Ribbon Along Bank Held a Big Fish

A long smooth pool is situated near the bottom of the left channel, and that is where I resumed fishing. Before casting, I observed four or five trout dimpling the surface. I decided to abandon the hopper and nymphs in the low and slow moving pool to avoid splashy casts and the risk of spooking the fish. I knotted a peacock hippie stomper to my line and then added a size 16 light gray deer hair caddis on a one foot extension. I was surprised when a ten inch brown trout smacked the caddis, but after the initial success both flies were either refused or ignored.

A very nice rainbow trout was feeding regularly fifteen feet above me and to the left, and I could easily observe its reaction to my flies. The trout ignored them. I exchanged the caddis for a size 22 CDC blue wing olive, and the observable trout paid no attention, although it feasted on small naturals. I gave up on the CDC olive and replaced it with a size 18 black parachute ant, and a small brown trout momentarily shed its selectivity, and it ate the ant. I tried the ant on several other recent risers, but its effectiveness ended, and I switched back to a size 16 light gray deer hair caddis. I moved to the top of the left braid, and I netted another small brown on the caddis, before I climbed the bank and returned to the right fork when looking upstream.

Cube Pool Again

I decided to fish the same water that I covered previously, however, on the second cycle I went to a double dry. I opted for a size 14 parachute green drake and a light gray size 16 deer hair caddis. Suddenly the caddis became a hot fly, and I built the fish count to sixteen. When I arrived at the cube pool, quite a few fish were rising, and I could feel the energy of the hatch. I flicked a fifteen foot cast to the tail of the pool, and a fine thirteen inch brown instantly grabbed the caddis. Perhaps I stumbled on to the answer with my caddis fly selection?

Chunk of Butter

Bottom of Cube Pool

I began spraying casts to the places that displayed recent rises, and the caddis was ignored, but several decent browns sucked in the parachute green drake. As this was transpiring, I spotted some naturals, and they were size 16 pale morning dens. I removed the caddis and replaced it with a size 16 light gray comparadun, and suddenly the trout exhibited interest once again in my second fly. I stuck with the green drake and comparadun and boosted the fish count to twenty-two, before I stripped in the flies and hooked them to my rod guide.

One of the Better Ones

By 4:30PM some light rain descended, and I reached a turning point. I either had to wade to the bank and dig out my raincoat or quit for the day. Given the time and my fish count of twenty-two, I chose the latter and hiked back to the car.

Right of Rock Was Home

Tuesday evolved into a rather successful day on the Frying Pan River. I landed twenty-two fish, and at least ten were respectable browns in the twelve to fourteen inch range. I was ready to write off the day as a disappointment at 2:00PM, but late hatches and a dry fly approach created a major turnaround. I never totally dialed in the hatch, but I experimented enough to create decent action and a successful day. I suspect that the sudden chill sent the trout into lethargy, and that explained the late afternoon hatching activity. This may have been my last visit to the Frying Pan River in 2025, and if so, I can appreciate two very fine days in the tailwater.

Fish Landed: 22

Beaver Creek – 09/22/2025

Time: 12:00PM – 3:00PM

Location: National Forest Land

Beaver Creek 09/22/2025 Photo Album

Note: In order to protect small high country streams, I have chosen to change the name for a few. This particular creek happens to be one of them. Excessive exposure could lead to crowding and lower fish densities.

I decided to pay daughter, Amy, another visit, as she lives in the heart of some excellent fishing destinations. I departed Denver on Monday morning and made the drive to the western slope. I arrived at my planned fishing destination and immediately prepared to fish. My casting tool was my Orvis Access four weight, since I was about to fish a relatively small mountain creek.

Once I was prepared, I completed a .8 mile hike in a constant ascent, and then I cut down the bank to a medium sized log, where I consumed my lunch. By the time I was prepared to fish, it was noon.

Lunch Spot

While I ate lunch, I overlooked a nice deep hole just below a small spillway over a log and above some overhanging branches. After lunch, just for kicks, I dropped a cast in the five foot by three foot space, and a nice eleven inch rainbow slammed the peacock hippie stomper.

Watched Me Eat Lunch

At the outset I prospected with a solo hippie stomper. For the first hour I moved steadily up the stream and built the fish count to seven. I experienced refusals and temporary hookups, but when I encountered a spot with decent depth and moderate current, I generally interacted with a fish. Toward the end of this time frame, however, the refusals became more frequent, and I felt like prime spots were not delivering as expected.

So Colorful

I paused and added an ultra zug bug on a one foot dropper to the stomper. The change worked miracles, and suddenly decent rainbows began to materialize from the better locations, as most snatched the ultra zug bug.

Ooh. What a Hole.

By 1:30PM a dark gray cloud floated overhead, and I quickly waded to an open spot on the shore and extracted my raincoat and pulled it on. I was outfitted with my rain shell just as the rain intensified, and for a brief amount of time I was pelted with tiny white ice pellets the size of a pea.

Parr Markings Visible

I weathered the brief storm and continued to compile netted fish. I got above a small tributary, and the stream narrowed, while the gradient increased. My catch rate slowed, as there were fewer prime fish holding spots. I boosted the fish count to twenty-eight, and once again the sky darkened. In this instance the blackness was accompanied by thunder and a couple visible streaks of lightning. I climbed the bank and found a large evergreen with dry soil beneath it. I crowded under the tree to wait out the storm.

Another Hot Spot

By now it was 2:50PM, and by 3:00PM the rain intensified. The temperature dropped significantly, and the rain created small streams of run off on the trail. I decided to abandon thoughts of resuming my day of fishing, and I marched back to the parking lot.

Some Length Here

Monday was a numbers day. My largest fish may have reached twelve inches, and of course the count include a bunch of six and seven inch dinks, but there were enough ten to eleven inch feisty ‘bows to maintain my interest. I love the surprise of a take by a wild rainbow in a small stream regardless of the size.

Fish Landed: 28